A 99 Metascore and a new all-time benchmark
The launch-day critical verdict on Grand Theft Auto 6 is now part of video game history: Rockstar’s long-awaited sequel is sitting at a 99 Metascore and has been placed at number one on Metacritic’s all-time games list, according to reporting published on November 18, 2026 . That is the headline behind the record: not merely that GTA 6 received near-perfect reviews, but that its aggregate standing has pushed it above the most famous benchmark in review-score history.
VGC reported that GTA 6 held a 99 on both PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X/S at the time of its check, with the PS5 score based on 109 reviews and the Xbox Series X/S score based on nine reviews . The outlet also noted the key distinction that makes this record more than a simple tie: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time also has a 99 Metascore, but Metacritic’s internal, more granular calculations put GTA 6 first on the site’s Best Games of All Time list .
That nuance matters. On the public-facing Metacritic scale, scores are rounded to whole numbers, which is why GTA 6 and Ocarina of Time can both appear as 99. But if two games share the same rounded Metascore, the underlying weighted average can still differ. Current reporting indicates that GTA 6’s underlying position is strong enough for it to be listed first, ahead of Ocarina of Time, SoulCalibur, Super Mario Galaxy 2, and Grand Theft Auto IV .
The review wave was unusually large
The record is even more striking because the sample size is enormous by historical standards. Make Tech Easier recorded GTA 6 at a 99 Metascore from 109 critic reviews shortly after the embargo lifted, and noted that the review count had jumped from 100 to 109 in under two minutes while the score stayed at 99 . That pace suggests the first wave was not a small cluster of handpicked early notices, but a broad and fast-moving critical consensus.
Other reports later in the day showed the number climbing even higher. Gadgets Now reported a 99 Metascore from 148 critic reviews, with every counted review sitting in Metacritic’s positive band, and an OpenCritic average of 98 from 62 critics with 100 percent recommending the game . VICE similarly reported that the game had earned a 99 Metascore from 144 critic reviews and described it as the highest-rated game of all time according to Metacritic .
The review count is central to the story because Ocarina of Time’s historic 99 was built in a very different media era, with far fewer reviews counted. VGC reported that Ocarina of Time is the only other game on Metacritic’s all-time list with a 99, while Nintendo-focused coverage noted that its score came from 22 critic reviews compared with more than one hundred for GTA 6 . In other words, GTA 6 is not just matching an old number; it is doing so under the weight of a much larger modern review ecosystem.
Why critics are calling it a generational release
The strongest theme across the coverage is scale. Critics are praising GTA 6 as a game that expands Rockstar’s open-world formula rather than simply repeating it. VGC’s own review verdict, referenced in its news report, described the game as “the game of the generation” and credited Rockstar with a modern masterpiece whose open world excels in storytelling, gameplay, visuals, music, and technology .
VICE’s roundup highlighted a similar pattern, reporting that outlets such as IGN, GameSpot, GamesRadar+, Eurogamer, The Guardian, VGC, Push Square, Game Informer, The Washington Post, Edge, and Forbes were among those awarding top marks or equivalent perfect scores . The same report identified several recurring areas of praise: the density of Leonida, the freedom of player experimentation, the return to Vice City, and the story built around Jason and Lucia .
Gadgets Now’s synthesis of nine longer reviews also found that critics were repeatedly singling out Leonida, Rockstar’s fictional Florida, as the main achievement. The report described reviewers praising the world’s reactivity, technical polish, character work, and sense of life between missions . It also noted that Jason Duval and Lucia Caminos emerged as a major point of critical interest, with several reviews treating their relationship as the emotional center of the crime story .
That point is important because it shows why the 99 is not only about technical spectacle. A highly detailed city can impress for a few hours; a record-setting critical response usually requires more. The current reviews suggest that critics see GTA 6 as a fusion of systems, narrative, performance, and world-building — the kind of release where the open world is not just a backdrop for missions, but the reason the story feels convincing.
The score is record-breaking, but still dynamic
Even at 99, the score should be understood as a live launch-window figure. Make Tech Easier emphasized that its Metacritic check was a snapshot and that the count was still rising as reviews were being added . Gadgets Now made the same point, explaining that both Metacritic and OpenCritic figures can move over the coming days as additional reviews enter the count .
That does not weaken the achievement. If anything, holding a 99 while the critic count moves above one hundred is the reason the result is so exceptional. Many acclaimed games open high and then drift downward as more outlets publish. GTA 6’s current distinction is that the early expansion of the sample did not immediately pull it out of record territory.
The comparison to past Rockstar releases also underlines the size of the leap. Gadgets Now reported that GTA 6’s 99 surpassed Rockstar’s previous Metacritic best, Grand Theft Auto IV at 98, while Grand Theft Auto V and Red Dead Redemption 2 each sat at 97 in the comparison used by the report . That places GTA 6 above not only most games ever reviewed, but also above the studio’s own most acclaimed modern work.
The Ocarina of Time comparison is unavoidable
Every all-time-score story eventually leads back to Ocarina of Time. For more than two decades, the 1998 Nintendo 64 classic has functioned as the symbolic ceiling for critical acclaim in games. GTA 6 reaching the same public score — and being placed ahead on Metacritic’s all-time list by internal ranking — is therefore culturally significant as well as statistically notable .
The comparison is imperfect, as all cross-era comparisons are. Ocarina of Time arrived in a smaller review ecosystem, at a time when 3D adventure design was still being defined. GTA 6 arrives in a much larger, more fragmented critical environment, after years of audience hype, leaks, delays, and scrutiny. That makes its achievement different rather than automatically greater.
Still, the pressure on GTA 6 was extraordinary. It followed Grand Theft Auto V, one of the most commercially dominant games ever released, and it arrived after more than a decade of expectation. A merely excellent sequel might have been praised and then absorbed into the normal launch cycle. A 99 Metascore from a huge review pool turns the launch into an industry event.
What the critics are not ignoring
The record does not mean reviewers found no flaws. Gadgets Now reported recurring deductions and criticisms around a 30 frames-per-second cap, some slower stretches late in the story, and controls that some critics found fiddly . That is a useful reminder that a perfect or near-perfect score in games criticism does not mean an absence of imperfections; it means the reviewer judged the total achievement to outweigh them.
The early reporting also shows that performance and platform context matter. The strongest and most numerous data points currently concern the console versions, particularly PlayStation 5, where most reviews appear to have been counted first . GTA 6’s broader reputation may still evolve as more players finish the story, user scores open, patches arrive, and any future platform releases are announced or reviewed.
For now, though, the critical record belongs to the launch-window console version. The user score was still listed as “tbd” in Make Tech Easier’s check, meaning the current story is specifically about professional critics rather than the wider audience response . That distinction should stay clear in any discussion of the record.
Why this record matters
Review aggregates are not the final word on art, and no single score can capture the full experience of a game this large. But Metacritic records matter because they shape how an industry remembers its turning points. When a title reaches 99 from such a broad review base, it becomes a reference point for the generation around it.
For Rockstar, the result is a validation of a long development cycle and a risky level of expectation. For players, it signals that the sequel has not merely survived the hype but converted it into critical consensus. For the wider games business, it resets the conversation about what a blockbuster open-world release can still achieve.
As of the latest reports from November 18, 2026, the working headline holds: GTA 6 has set a new record as the highest-rated video game of all time by its current Metacritic placement, while sharing the public 99 score with Ocarina of Time . The number may move as more reviews are added, but the launch-day verdict is already historic.

