A 99 that changes the conversation
Grand Theft Auto 6 has done what the modern review ecosystem had made seem almost impossible: it has reached a 99 Metascore and tied The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time at the top of Metacritic’s all-time games list . According to Paul Tassi’s report, Rockstar’s sequel was sitting at 99 with more than 100 reviews counted, specifically 109 at the time of writing, and 80 of those reviews were perfect scores . That matters because Ocarina of Time’s 99 has long stood as the defining number in games criticism: the original Nintendo 64 release, not the 2026 remake, was the lone benchmark that every new “best game ever” contender had to face .
The headline is simple, but the implications are bigger. This is not merely another highly reviewed Rockstar game. Grand Theft Auto IV and Grand Theft Auto V were already part of the elite review-score conversation, but GTA 6 reaching 99 places it in a rarer category: a direct statistical tie with the game often treated as Metacritic’s all-time critical ceiling . In an era with more outlets, more review philosophies, more platform-performance scrutiny and more polarized fandoms, a 99 average across such a large batch of reviews is not just a great launch; it is an industry event.
Why the tie with Ocarina of Time is so unusual
The comparison with Ocarina of Time is powerful because it bridges two very different eras of games media. Ocarina’s 99 belongs to 1998, when the review field was smaller and fewer publications contributed to long-term aggregator averages. GTA 6’s 99 arrived in 2026 with a much larger review pool, meaning Rockstar’s score had to survive far more critical inputs before matching Nintendo’s historic number . That does not automatically make one game “better” than the other; Metacritic is an average, not a court verdict. But it does make the feat statistically extraordinary.
It is also important to separate three Zelda-related stories that are easy to collapse into one. The all-time record belongs to the original The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. The 2026 Ocarina of Time remake has been part of this year’s broader review conversation, but the record GTA 6 has matched is the original’s 99, not the remake’s score . That distinction is essential because the story is not “GTA beats the remake.” It is that GTA 6 has tied the long-standing Metacritic summit held by the 1998 classic .
The score is historic, but not frozen
The current number should be treated as a milestone, not as a final engraving. The report that identified the 99 noted the number of counted reviews at the time it was written, and Metacritic scores can move as more critics publish and are added to the aggregate . A single lower review will not necessarily collapse a score with more than 100 reviews behind it, but movement from 99 to 98 is mathematically possible as the sample grows. That uncertainty is part of the story: GTA 6 has tied the record now, but the next wave of criticism will determine whether the tie holds.
This is especially relevant because the game’s public release lands on November 19, while the review wave arrived just before launch . That timing creates a classic pre-release review window: critics with early access have delivered the first consensus, while broader technical impressions, post-launch updates, platform comparisons and audience reactions will follow. For now, the critical consensus is overwhelming. But “highest-rated ever” is a live status, not a trophy locked in a cabinet.
What critics are praising
The critical response is not only about scale, budget or brand power. The Guardian’s review frames GTA 6 as Rockstar’s most detailed virtual world yet, but also as a tonal shift centered on Jason and Lucia, whose relationship gives the game an emotional spine unusual for the series . Keza MacDonald describes a game that still contains the foul-mouthed chaos associated with Grand Theft Auto, while also emphasizing empathy, intimacy and the bond between its fugitive leads . That combination helps explain why the game is not being praised solely as a technical flex.
Kotaku’s review also emphasizes the world’s density and the sense that GTA 6 is the result of a decade-long accumulation of resources, craft and detail . Zack Zwiezen writes about small interactions, environmental texture, a reactive version of Vice City and a game world that feels designed to be lived in rather than simply cleared . In that reading, GTA 6’s achievement is not just that it is massive; it is that the size appears to support character, atmosphere and player curiosity.
Those reactions line up with the Metacritic result. Perfect-score waves usually happen when critics converge around more than polish. They need to see significance: a game that moves expectations for its genre, platform generation or medium. In GTA 6’s case, reviewers appear to be responding to a combination of open-world density, narrative intimacy, technical ambition and Rockstar’s ability to make a familiar formula feel newly consequential .
A Rockstar record and a Metacritic stress test
For Rockstar, the 99 is a new peak in a franchise already associated with enormous critical numbers. The studio has long been judged by the impossible standards created by its own back catalogue, and that made GTA 6’s review moment unusually high-pressure. Anything in the low-to-mid 90s would have been excellent for most games, but for GTA 6 it would have been framed by some as falling short of the event’s scale. Tying Ocarina of Time changes that narrative completely .
It also stress-tests how people talk about aggregate scores. A Metascore can summarize a critical trend, but it cannot capture every tension around a game: performance, politics, satire, labor, price, accessibility, online plans or long-tail support. The Guardian’s review praises the game’s astonishing world while underlining its adult, deliberately excessive content . Kotaku’s review similarly calls the game remarkable while presenting it as overwhelming in scope . These are not small caveats, but they are part of why the score is interesting: critics are not saying GTA 6 is modest or flawless in some abstract vacuum. They are saying its ambition, execution and experience outweigh the reservations strongly enough to produce one of the most positive review aggregates ever recorded.
What it means for Zelda’s legacy
The tie does not diminish Ocarina of Time. If anything, it reinforces the scale of its achievement. A game released in 1998 remained the top reference point for nearly three decades, and even the most anticipated entertainment launch of 2026 could only match it, not surpass it, at least at this stage . Zelda’s position as the yardstick remains intact because a tie still keeps it at the summit.
The more interesting legacy question is whether GTA 6 can hold the number once the review pool expands. If it stays at 99, the conversation around “highest-rated game ever” becomes permanently plural: Ocarina of Time and Grand Theft Auto 6, two open-world milestones separated by 28 years, sitting together. If it slips to 98, the story becomes different but still extraordinary: GTA 6 would remain one of the best-reviewed games ever, while Ocarina would continue as the sole 99. Either outcome keeps this launch in the record books.
The bottom line
As of the latest reported review wave, Grand Theft Auto 6 has tied The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time as the highest-rated game ever on Metacritic, with a 99 score built from more than 100 critic reviews . The achievement is historic because it matches a record that had defined the top of the medium since 1998 . It is also provisional because new reviews can still alter the average .
For now, Rockstar has delivered the rarest kind of review moment: not just acclaim, not just a blockbuster launch, but a numerical tie with gaming’s most famous critical benchmark. GTA 6 may or may not hold the 99 as the count grows. But for this moment, it stands beside Ocarina of Time at the very top.

